The purpose of the Fluid Statics lab is to practice and compare various methods of calculating a buoyant force exerted on a object submerged in a fluid by the fluid.
A. Underwater Weighing Method
This method of buoyant force calculation is based on a theoretical free body diagram of an object submerged in a fluid.
The setup:
|
Our group assembles the appartus for Method A
(Apparatus is highlighted, top arrow directed at force probe,
and lower arrow directed at hanging cylinder) |
- A solid cylinder is suspended on a string from a force probe
- A beaker of water (fluid) is raised such that the solid cylinder becomes submerged in the water, but does not touch the bottom surface of the beaker
- A free-body diagram shows the 3 primary forces acting on the cylinder
- The tension in the string (upward)
- The weight of the cyclinder (downward)
- The buoyant force (upward)
Measurements and Calculations:
|
Calculations for Underwater Weighing Method |
- The mass of the cylinder was measured on a balance (110.62 +/- 0.05 grams)
- The calculated Weight of the cylinder, W=mg, was calculated as 1.084 N
- The Tension reading by the force probe was read as 0.725 +/- 0.1 N
- Solving for the Buoyant force when summing the vertical forces in the free-body diagram, we calculate the Buoyant force to be 0.360 +/- 0.05 N
B. Displaced Fluid Method
This method of buoyant force calculation is based on Archimede's principle, which states that "A fluid exerts an upward force on an object immersed in the fluid equal to the weight of the fluid displaced by the body."
The Setup:
|
The cylinder completely submerged in the water.
Note that the water level remains at the brim.
|
- A beaker is filled to the brim with water
- A second beaker is held below the spout of the first beaker to collect the overflow of water as the cylinder is slowly lowered
Measurements and Calculations:
|
Calculations for Displaced Fluid Method |
C. Volume of Object Method
This method of Buoyant Force calculation is similar to Part B in that it is calculated based on the amount of water expected to be displaced by the volume of the cylinder. This approach differs in that the volume is measured by the dimensions of the cylinder rather than by the fluid it would displace in a beaker filled to the brim with water.
The Setup:
|
The physical dimesions of the cylinder are measured |
- The height and diameter of the cylinder are measured
Calculations and Measurements:
|
Calculations for Volume of Object Method |
The height of the cylinder was measured as 0.074 +/- 0.0005 m
The diameter of the cylinder was measured as 0.023 +/- 0.005 m
The volume of the cylinder was calculated as 3.07 x 10^-5 m^3 (V=pi*r^2*h)
Solving for the Buoyant Force (being equal to the expected weight of displaced water), it was calculated to be 0.301301 +/- 0.0132 N (density of water (1000 kg/M^3) * V* g)
Results:
Each of the 3 methods practiced produced calculations for the buoyant force that are relatively close to one another with Method C deviating furthest from the group. Uncertaintly of our measurements were propogated based on the partial derivative method.
The method believed to be most accurate would be Method B where it's experiment was closest to that actual definition of buoyant force and having all measurements taken with the same instrument. Methods A and C required measurements from a combination of instruments (A) or having multiple measurements that could propogate a larger uncertainty (C).
It should be noted that had the cylinder in Method A touched the bottom of the beaker, it would have produced a tension measurement too low and, in turn, a buoyant force too high.